Skip to main content

In Response to COVID-19, the Oklahoma Supreme Court Claims Power to “Suspend” Valid Laws


I have referred often to the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s “lawmaking” or to justices acting like “legislators in black robes” as rhetorical devices intended to illustrate a point about judicial activism. I never imagined the Court would go so far as to actually begin legislating. With its latest actions, however, it seems the Court views the exigencies created by our current public health woes as a greenlight to literally change the law in Oklahoma.

On Friday of last week, the Oklahoma Supreme Court issued (and the Court of Criminal Appeals signed off on) an “Emergency Joint Order” declaring that “all deadlines and procedures whether prescribed by statute, rule or order in any civil, juvenile or criminal case, shall be suspended through May 15, 2020” due to COVID-19 (emphasis added). The Court made this suspension specifically applicable to statutes of limitation in all civil cases. The Court had, on March 16, issued a similar order suspending deadlines for 30 days.

These Emergency Orders were not issued in the context of some pending case before the Court or in response to a litigant petitioning the Court for relief, but simply as a decree from on high, not subject to debate or appeal.

Where the Court thinks it gets the authority to suspend duly enacted statutes is anyone’s guess, as the Order includes no citations to statute, the constitution, or caselaw.

I suspect the Court views this as within a combination of their general administrative authority and their “superintending control” over the courts granted by the Oklahoma Constitution, Article 7, Sections 4 and 6. Again, we don’t know, because the Court didn’t see a need to explain where it gets this power. But the idea that these parts of the Constitution grant the Court the power to suspend the application of valid laws stretches the Constitution to the point that it ceases to limit judicial activity in any meaningful way. Justices are not kings, and even vague constitutional provisions provide some constraints on their powers.

To understand the significance of this action, consider just the suspension of statutes of limitation. For the unacquainted, statutes of limitation are kind of a big deal. They are the drop dead date by which an aggrieved individual must file his lawsuit, after which he is forever barred from seeking relief in court. They are imposed because the more time that elapses from an event that gives rise to a lawsuit, the more likely it is that evidence grows stale and witnesses become unavailable or their memories become foggy. The practical result is that even the most severely injured person who has a totally legitimate legal claim against a defendant is completely prohibited from collecting a dime if he waits too long to file his lawsuit. Deciding when this date falls (should it be one year? Two? Should there even be a limitation in certain types of suits?) is a matter very important to plaintiffs and defendants alike.

The line must be drawn somewhere, and in Oklahoma, the deadlines are imposed by statute. That is, by the elected legislature. That means after a legislative process, with opportunity for debate, and by people who can be voted out of office for drawing the line in a place their constituents think unwise or unfair.

Incidentally, I think it may very well be necessary to extend these deadlines, given the shutdown policy the rest of the government has imposed. It is difficult for anyone to get any work done in this environment, and lawyers are no exception. To enforce deadlines against litigants in this environment would most likely result in unfair disadvantage to someone, somewhere. But this is a public policy change that requires a law passed by the Legislature (which is still in session, by the way) and signed by the Governor, not an emergency fiat issued from nine lawyers in Oklahoma City.

Or it could possibly be subsequently decided by courts as part of a case or controversy for which a court has jurisdiction if there is some other, valid legal authority to do so. Courts have come up with various interpretations of written statutes of limitations, finding them to be “tolled” or extended, such as when a person is injured but does not discover the injury until a later time or some exigent circumstance precluded timely filing of the lawsuit. Some of these interpretations are better reasoned than others, but all of them are at least rooted in the law as written by the elected branches.

More importantly, such interpretations are developed in the context of a case with an actual plaintiff, an actual defendant, a legal dispute, and a request for relief from the court—in short, when there is a live case or controversy for which the court has a constitutional basis to weigh in. They are not pulled from thin air by an unelected and unaccountable court and imposed on all of society. Courts are not supposed to be in the business of—and are structurally ill-equipped for—unprompted policymaking decrees of general applicability.

This is of a different category than the Governor, as the chief executive, exercising emergency powers to do things (like temporarily closing businesses) he normally would have no power to do. For one, executives are given this type of power in the constitution, specifically because an emergency may arise that requires decisive action outside of normal procedures. Moreover, there are checks on the Governor. Citizens can go to court if he overreaches, and the legislature can reign him in with legislation, the power of the purse, and even impeachment. The legislature is also granted special powers in an emergency, but there are also checks on it. The Governor can exercise his veto, and the courts can invalidate legislative enactments. The people have the ultimate check over the political branches at the ballot box.

As with most of the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s excesses, there is no meaningful check on this action by the Court. 

Process and seemingly small details matter in legal proceedings in a way they do not when we cut corners in other aspects of life but end up at the “right” result. If your co-worker forgets it’s his turn to drive the carpool and you end up a little late to the office, c’est la vie, you might be inconvenienced but you still made it to work. If the courts start ignoring written rules, you might lose your liberty.

What will stop the Court from exercising its newfound power in other contexts, where the need for such action is less clear, or where reasonable minds differ as to the extent of the emergency? What precedent does this set? Given the repeated overreach by this particular Court, chronicled in great detail, we should not take a casual view of such deviations from the norm.

They have earned a short leash.

Benjamin Lepak is Legal Fellow at the 1889 Institute. He can be reached at blepak@1889institute.org.

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the official position of 1889 Institute.

Popular posts from this blog

OKC Public Schools Elevating a Privileged Elite over Oklahoma Taxpayers

The hypocrisy of the Soviet Union’s pretense of egalitarianism was well known enough to be the subject of mockery and parody. Ronald Reagan never tired of the jokes . Soviet communism espoused equality, but the reality is that party apparatchiks and government officials enjoyed special perks that no one else had access to. This special class wasn’t officially paid much more than the average skilled worker, but enjoyed privileges like dachas on the coast or countryside, special stores with imported goods and without the endless lines that were commonplace everywhere else, and more advanced medical treatment. For all their talk about eliminating class distinctions, the Soviet nomenklatura —those “doing the people’s work”—could feather their nest with the best of ‘em. Apparently, a similar attitude reigns in our government schools. Our friends at OCPA report that Oklahoma City Public Schools (OKCPS) will not offer in-person instruction to students for the first nine weeks of school this ...

COVID-19 Exposes TSET’s Uselessness: Let’s Get Rid of It

After more than a month of COVID-19 house arrest , Oklahoma is reopening. However, the government-created economic disaster that shutdown orders have caused will be studied by epidemiologists, economists, and other social scientists for decades to come. In the meantime, we have to deal with the consequences as they occur, everything from a lack of toilet paper on store shelves (hopefully, that’s over) and hair that’s grown too long to what will undoubtedly be a host of bankruptcies. In the meantime, there is a timely question that truly ought to be answered in Oklahoma. Where has TSET (Tobacco Settlement Endowment Trust) been in this time of crisis? Recall that TSET was created as a quasi-independent government by constitutional amendment as part of the 46-state tobacco settlement wherein tobacco companies agreed to pay states as reimbursement for the Medicaid costs of treating tobacco users for tobacco-induced illnesses. Instead of using the money to reduce taxes for Oklahom...

America’s Public Schools Fail Black Children, School Choice Empowers Them to Overcome

A consistent feature of racists through history is that they have fully understood the power of education, or the lack of education, as a tool of oppression. Extraordinary efforts were taken to keep black slaves illiterate, including killing those who deigned to learn to read. After the Civil War, black schools were frequent targets of attack. It should be no surprise that the longest and hardest fight in the Jim Crow South was over public school segregation. Segregationists worked to keep African Americans from lunch counters and in the back of city buses, but they fought like hell to keep black kids out of white schools. As our nation convulses with discussions of systemic racism, nearly all of the focus has been on questions of policing and the use of force. This is appropriate, of course. But I’d like to highlight a less discussed institution for which a strong case can be made that systemic racism prevails: public education.   An accepted definition of “systemic” or “structu...

A Teacher Walkout Leader’s Distorted View of School Choice

The Tulsa World recently published a piece by a leader of the teacher walkout a few years ago predictably opposing Governor Stitt’s proposal to expand the Equal Opportunity Education Scholarship program. There is much to take issue with in the piece, which is full of disinformation, but perhaps the most preposterous claim is the following: You’ve probably also heard of “school choice.” The term is extremely misleading because it implies that parents don’t have a choice, when the reality is every parent already has school choice for their child. Parents can choose to send their child to a public school, private school, religious school or even home school. School choice isn’t about giving parents more options. It’s about using taxpayer dollars to give wealthy families a discount on their choice of school. (emphasis added) Try telling that to the truancy officer. The model of public education in America is that we assign every student to a government school base...