Skip to main content

The Unfairness of Concentrated Wealth is NOTHING Compared to the Unfairness of Redistributing It


Socialist types like to accuse rich corporate types of having “too much” wealth. Simple fairness, they claim, dictates that one person should not have so much when so many have so little. But if we’re going to talk about fairness, let’s really give it fair consideration. That means looking beyond the petty jealousy and thinking about the fairness of seizing wealth from those who earned it and giving it to those who did not.  


How did the wealthy get that way? The socialist types claim that the greedy capitalists exploit their workers and their consumers. Is that true? Let’s start with the workers. Jeff Bezos may be greedy. I wouldn’t know, I’ve never met him. But I did work for him - in fact I hired other people to work for him. So I can say with reasonable certainty that he hasn’t created his enormous wealth by exploiting his workers. They were all there voluntarily. 


Before attending law school, I spent several months working for the temp agency that hires seasonal workers for Amazon warehouses. I saw a lot of people thrilled to get a job, but you know what I didn’t see? Anyone being dragged to my office by the Agents of Amazon, bound to a chair, and told they had no choice but to work. I didn’t see anyone forced to work against their will. What I did see was relieved faces when people learned they had just gotten a job. For some it was a chance to earn a little extra money to pay for Christmas presents. For others it was a fresh start. A few were there at the insistence of a parent or significant other, and were less sanguine about the prospects of spending 12 hours packing boxes in a warehouse. I don’t blame them. But it certainly beats sitting at home hoping someone will come along and solve your problems for you. Working a job - even as an Amazon warehouse packer - beats searching for a job. 


So if Bezos isn’t exploiting the worker (since the worker is there voluntarily), he must exploit his customers, right? Why do people buy from Amazon? I don’t want this to sound like an ad for Amazon, as I have some serious concerns about the way they dominate the market, and about their open acceptance of corporate welfare. But it’s no surprise they have amassed a loyal following. They tend to have low prices. Perhaps someone else offers a single item for a lower price, but overall, if you purchase the bulk of your goods from Amazon, you’ll probably spend less than if you bought from any other single source. 


Price is important, but you also want to make sure you’re getting the right product. Amazon has reviews on almost every product they sell. It’s pretty easy to judge quality. Speaking of products, Amazon has them all. With few exceptions it’s difficult to find a product category that Amazon doesn’t carry. Finally, Amazon is easy. It’s easy to find what you’re looking for, and you don’t even have to leave your house. Amazon has always catered to shut-ins. It’s 2020; we’ve created an excess of shut-ins. 


Given all these appealing aspects, is it any wonder Amazon is making money hand over fist? I don’t know about you, but I’ve never been visited by the Agents of Amazon, demanding that I click “buy” or see my house mysteriously go up in flames. 


If Bezos doesn’t exploit workers, and he doesn’t exploit consumers, how did he amass such a great wealth? He created it, by providing value to his customers. Somewhere along the line, people decided that the ease and convenience of using Amazon outweighed whatever practical or moral compunctions they had about giving their money to someone who had all the hallmarks of becoming a billionaire. That is, people let their self-interest guide their purchasing decisions. 


So, let’s reconsider the fairness of redistributing Bezos’ great wealth. He created a company. He hired workers who chose to do the job and take the pay that was offered, without a gun to their head or the threat of being put in jail. He offered goods to customers in a competitive market. They chose to buy from him. Without a gun to their head or the threat of being put in jail. If you can point to someone who got rich through deception or corrupt manipulation of government, then you might have an argument for redistributing some portion of their wealth. 1889 is vehemently opposed to any kind of corporate welfare or favoritism. But certain elements of society want to send agents of the government to Bezos’ house — simply because he is wealthy — demand that he hand over the bulk of his wealth, or be put in jail. If he refuses, these agents will use their guns to persuade him. The wealth will then be given to people based on how little they have - that is, how little value they have created for others. Tell me, what’s fair about that?


Mike Davis is a Research Fellow at 1889 Institute. He can be reached at mdavis@1889institute.org. 


The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the official position of 1889 Institute.

Popular posts from this blog

OKC Public Schools Elevating a Privileged Elite over Oklahoma Taxpayers

The hypocrisy of the Soviet Union’s pretense of egalitarianism was well known enough to be the subject of mockery and parody. Ronald Reagan never tired of the jokes . Soviet communism espoused equality, but the reality is that party apparatchiks and government officials enjoyed special perks that no one else had access to. This special class wasn’t officially paid much more than the average skilled worker, but enjoyed privileges like dachas on the coast or countryside, special stores with imported goods and without the endless lines that were commonplace everywhere else, and more advanced medical treatment. For all their talk about eliminating class distinctions, the Soviet nomenklatura —those “doing the people’s work”—could feather their nest with the best of ‘em. Apparently, a similar attitude reigns in our government schools. Our friends at OCPA report that Oklahoma City Public Schools (OKCPS) will not offer in-person instruction to students for the first nine weeks of school this ...

Can Government Force You to Close Your Business?

1889 Institute takes no position on whether any or all of these measures are warranted or necessary, or whether their economic fallout would inflict more human suffering than they prevent. We are simply evaluating whether they are legal.   With the unprecedented (in the last 100 years at least) reaction surrounding the outbreak of Covid-19, questions that few living legal scholars have considered are suddenly relevant.   Can a quarantine be ordered?   Can a mass quarantine, lockdown, or “cordon sanitaire” be ordered? Can businesses be ordered to change their behavior?   Can businesses be ordered to close? Can state governments order these measures? Can local governments order these measures? My legal brief addresses these issues from a statutory point of view; it is clear that state law gives the governor and mayors broad authority in a state of emergency. They must, of course, do so in a neutral way that they reasonably believe will help preve...

America’s Public Schools Fail Black Children, School Choice Empowers Them to Overcome

A consistent feature of racists through history is that they have fully understood the power of education, or the lack of education, as a tool of oppression. Extraordinary efforts were taken to keep black slaves illiterate, including killing those who deigned to learn to read. After the Civil War, black schools were frequent targets of attack. It should be no surprise that the longest and hardest fight in the Jim Crow South was over public school segregation. Segregationists worked to keep African Americans from lunch counters and in the back of city buses, but they fought like hell to keep black kids out of white schools. As our nation convulses with discussions of systemic racism, nearly all of the focus has been on questions of policing and the use of force. This is appropriate, of course. But I’d like to highlight a less discussed institution for which a strong case can be made that systemic racism prevails: public education.   An accepted definition of “systemic” or “structu...

Shut Downs Likely to Result in More COVID-19 Deaths than if Nothing Were Done

More people will die as a result of COVID-19 because we closed the schools than would have if we’d kept the schools open or if we’d brought the kids back to school in summer. That is part of the message from Knut M. Wittkowski, who headed the Department of Biostatistics, Epidemiology, and Research Design at The Rockefeller University in New York, when he was interviewed around April 6. ( The Rockefeller University is a private graduate college focusing on biological and medical sciences, providing doctoral and postdoctoral education and with which 36 Nobel laureates have been affiliated.) In effect, the same message was given by experts cited by 1889 Institute in a March 24 statement decrying the plan to turn out public schools for the year. Dr. Wittkowski explains in detail that “herd immunity” is critical, indeed absolutely essential, to end a respiratory disease pandemic. Herd immunity occurs when at least 80 percent of a population has been exposed to the disease and...